The Honda S2000 is not advancing back. Honda’s PR has fabricated that abundant clear. The business case for a artlessly aspirated sports car benumbed on a committed belvedere awash at an attainable amount artlessly does not exist. The Borough Type R and, to a bottom extent, the Borough Si are the abandoned way advanced for the company’s adventurous options.
It makes sense. Developing a belvedere is ruinously expensive. Doing so for one car, not a agile of models, ambiguous impossible. Add in a committed agent that pushes the boundaries of achievement per liter and it’s adamantine to see how the S2000 anytime fabricated sense, let abandoned how a new one could possibly assignment out on paper. So Honda gives us cars like the 2020 Borough Si, fun and fast options congenital on boilerplate platforms, amortized over hundreds of bags of units to amuse the accounts department. And aback Road & Track has a abiding Borough Si to appraise and I accept a 2003 S2000 anchored alfresco my Brooklyn apartment, the allegory of the old way to the new came naturally.
© Mack Hogan 2003 honda s2000
Sit for one additional in the Si and you’ll already apprehension the payoffs of the Civic’s boilerplate roots. Its ancestors car cred makes it added ample inside, alike if you opt for the coupe. There’s a aback seat, a big trunk, and affluence of cubbies and accumulator pockets for aggregate that coagulates artlessly in a circadian driver. The S2000, on the added hand, does after barmy luxuries like a cuff box; there is a baby alcove amid the seats, addition one aloft that, one cupholder, and a aperture beneath that for change or cards.
That minimalism is additionally activated to the S2000’s complete insulation. Its top is cardboard thin, its berth loud behindhand of whether the windows and top are open. Ride abundance additionally suffers, partly due to its 15-inch beneath breadth and partly do to its added advancing tuning. The 2.0-liter AP1 agent sits about 4000 rpm in sixth accessory on the highway, all the bigger as the S2000 has finer no torque beneath that point. It is buzzy, eager, never acclimatized alike on a continued drive home. It is considerately not absolute acceptable at actuality a car, in that its interests lie alfresco the branch of active from actuality to there in a comfortable, airy manner.
The Civic, on the added hand, plays the role of circadian disciplinarian well. Its berth is hushed from alfresco noise, so abundant so that Honda pumps in acutely affected agent sounds through the speakers. Its ride is composed and soft, annealed abundant to accumulate aggregate buttoned bottomward but not harsh. The 1.5-liter turbo four fades abroad back put in sixth gear, accessible for a nice torquey canyon but never as abject as the 9000-rpm announcement in the S2000. It is considerately absolute acceptable at actuality a car, in that it will agilely doodle forth for hours after complaint, advice you steer, try to automatically abstain collisions, and accumulate you affiliated with CarPlay and a blow screen.
But you do not buy either of these cars because you artlessly charge a car to do accepted car things. The actuality of the Si presupposes that the accepted Borough is not abrading all of the appropriate itches, not absolutely the fun accustomed car that enthusiasts want. The Si, with 205 hp and a glossy six-speed manual, is declared to be the remedy. And yet, for all of the advantages of the Borough platform, the Si doesn’t absolutely succeed.
Make no mistake; this is a quick and able car. Its 6.3-second 0-60 time cannot absolutely bout the S2000’s (in the five-second range, admitting numbers vary), but acknowledgment to the turbo it feels abundant quicker at low speeds. It is buried and anticipated about corners, its advanced tires never acutely afflicted by the power. Trouble is, it aloof isn’t all that fun.
The 1.5 turbo is almighty but absolutely forgettable. It delivers its ability like every added baby turbocharged boilerplate engine, with a bit of lag afore a beachcomber of torque that dies out as you access redline. Aiguille ability (205 hp) comes at 5700 rpm, with aiguille torque (192 lb-ft) accessible at aloof 2100 rpm. There is no crescendo, no accolade for blame the engine, aloof a solid addition and a affected babble attempting to amuse your brain’s admiration for drama. The council is precise, dialed-in, and lifeless. It is no agnosticism bluff than a accepted Civic, yet not abundant added memorable.
The S2000 has its activating flaws too. The council is not about as concrete as you’d apprehend from a car like this and the AP1 is decumbent to breeze oversteer. Revs charge be managed consistently to break in VTEC—where best of the ability and torque is—and the agent babble isn’t as appropriate as the agent itself.
Yet this agent is an earworm. From the moment I aboriginal collection one at the Mid-Ohio academy in 2017, I knew I bare an S2000. Its gearbox is amid the best anytime built, its council fast and precise. It scoots its way out of corners, your base pulled forth for the ride acknowledgment to the above-the-rear-axle seating. Mostly, though, it’s aloof about the engine. Back the car crosses into VTEC territory, the amount of dispatch massively picks up, the S2000 beginning into activity and agreeable against its 9000-rpm redline. It will do this all day, ambitious that you exhausted the complete snot out of it if you appetite any performance. It is aloof in ambiguous driving; choke the activity out of it or get dusted by minivans. You artlessly accept to assignment for it.
There’s no acumen the Borough couldn’t be like this. The adrenaline hit of VTEC could calmly be accomplished with a beyond turbocharger that smacks you beyond the face as you cantankerous into the addition zone. Yet Honda chose to accomplish this Si added docile, added all-embracing quick. It requires aught bark in the game; you can canyon addition after downshifting, access a bend too fast alive it will never bite, and get the affecting soundtrack of a active agent after any of the absolute agent babble that could get annoying. It asks annihilation of you, accouterment headache-free buying yet not abundant for adopting abundant affecting attachment.
So it’s not the avant-garde S2000. The acceptable account is, acknowledgment to the Borough Type R, it doesn’t absolutely charge to be. That’s area the die-hards will go, the bodies accommodating to put up with a annealed ride and a absonant engine. Sure, it requires a heftier premium, but so did the S2000 in its day. The accuracy is, accomplished things crave some compromises. As abundant as I capital the Borough Si to be all the car for all the people, it isn’t. Annihilation anytime is.
Gallery: Every Hellcat-Powered Vehicle, Ranked (Road & Track)